Gen. Custer: "Come on you Wolverines!"

Submitted by Blue Balls Afire on November 22nd, 2021 at 2:03 PM

As we approach The Game, I’m reminded of another time when gray-clad invaders from the South tried to destroy the will of the people of the North.  Robert E. Lee invaded Pennsylvania in the summer of 1863 where his army could threaten Philadelphia, Baltimore, and Washington DC.  By bringing war to the North, and with a definitive triumph, he hoped to encourage the North to sue for peace.  Lee’s Army of Virginia met Gen. George Meade’s Army of the Potomac at Gettysburg on July 1, 1863.  Two days of brutal fighting resulted in a stalemate.  Lee ordered a final charge against the Union center on the third day of battle in order to gain the definitive triumph he so desperately wanted.  Less well known is what happened three miles northeast of Gettysburg in what is now called the Battle of East Cavalry Field.  Here, a general by the name of George Armstrong Custer led his outnumbered Michigan troopers against the finest cavalry the world had ever seen.

Gen. JEB Stuart had reached Gettysburg the day before.  Eager to make amends for his perceived failure to support Lee during the first two days of battle, Stuart was determined to outflank Meade and drive into the Union rear to wreak havoc and cut off any Union retreat following Pickett’s charge.  At about 11:00 a.m. on July 3, Stuart’s three brigades reached Cress Ridge, joining the one already there, just north of East Cavalry Field, and signaled Lee that he was in position by ordering the firing of four guns, one in each direction of the compass. This was a foolish error because he also alerted Gen. David McM. Gregg, the Union commander in the region, to his presence.  Gregg had two cavalry brigades; one under Col. John B. McIntosh and the other was the newly formed "Michigan Brigade" of Brig. Gen. Custer. Custer was assigned to the division of Brig. Gen. Judson Kilpatrick but happened to be on loan to David Gregg and requested permission from Gregg to join his fight.

Stuart's plan had been to pin down McIntosh's and Custer's skirmishers around the Rummel farm and swing over Cress Ridge, around the left flank of the defenders, but the Federal skirmish line pushed back tenaciously; the troopers from the 5th Michigan Cavalry were armed with Spencer repeating rifles, multiplying their firepower. Stuart decided on a direct cavalry charge to break their resistance. He ordered an assault by the 1st Virginia Cavalry, his own old regiment, now in Fitz Lee's brigade. The battle started in earnest at approximately 1:00 p.m.

Gregg ordered Custer to counterattack with the 7th Michigan. Custer personally led the regiment, shouting "Come on, you Wolverines!".  Waves of blue clad horsemen sporting the maize cavalry stripe, collided in furious fighting with gray southern troopers along the fence line on Rummel's farm. Seven hundred men fought at point-blank range across the fence with carbines, pistols and sabers. Custer's horse was shot out from under him, and he commandeered a bugler's horse.  Eventually enough of Custer's men were amassed to break down the fence, and caused the Virginians to retreat.

Stuart sent in reinforcements from three of his brigades: the 9th and 13th Virginia (Chambliss' Brigade), the 1st North Carolina and the Jeff Davis Legion (Hampton's) and squadrons from the 2nd Virginia (Fitz Lee's).  Custer was forced to pull back.

Stuart tried again for a breakthrough by sending in the bulk of Wade Hampton's brigade.  Hundreds of Confederate horsemen, accelerated in formation from a walk to a gallop, sabers flashing, calling forth "murmurs of admiration" from their Union targets.  Union horse artillery batteries attempted to block the advance with shell and canister, but the Confederates moved too quickly and were able to fill in for lost men, maintaining their momentum.  Then, once again, the cry "Come on, you Wolverines!" was heard as Custer and Col. Charles H. Town led the 1st Michigan Cavalry into the fray, also at a full gallop.  A trooper from one of Gregg's Pennsylvania regiments observed:

“As the two columns approached each other the pace of each increased, when suddenly a crash, like the falling of timber, betokened the crisis.  So sudden and violent was the collision that many of the horses were turned end over end and crushed their riders beneath them.”

As the horsemen fought desperately in the center, McIntosh personally led his brigade against Hampton's right flank while the 3rd Pennsylvania under Captain William E. Miller and 1st New Jersey hit Hampton's left from north of the Lott house. Hampton received a serious saber wound to the head; Custer lost his second horse of the day.  Assaulted from three sides, the Confederates withdrew.  The Federals had held.

So as The Game approaches, may we all get some inspiration from the maize and blue Michigan Cavalry at Gettysburg.  Although facing greater number and greater skill, the Michigan blue stopped the southern invaders dead in their tracks.  The Union, of course, would go on to win the battle of Gettysburg and eventually the war.  The tide had turned.  Go Blue!

[Source: Wikipedia and YouTube videos]

Gameboy

November 22nd, 2021 at 2:33 PM ^

Custer never had to deal with a bunch of fanboy zebras who will give calls after calls to OSU.

I still get livid thinking about that game where we the refs were patting the butts of OSU players and called PI every time there was an incompletion (and I am not even talking about the fact that they were stopped a yard short).

Until Warde gets really serious and makes sure that we get (at least) an unbiased set of ref's we are not going to win this game because with the talent deficit we have, we cannot overcome that when we have to go against the ref's too.

The computers give us better than 1/3 chance to win. But none of us think that we have that kind of a shot. I think most of that is due to the fact that we all know we are going to get boned by the refs in this game.

RGard

November 22nd, 2021 at 3:43 PM ^

True, but there is more to it.  In his previous attacks on the Indians, the Indians usually scattered so he thought he could get away with it again.

Stupidity is also a factor.  He turned down adding troops from the 2nd Cavalry. He really had no clue just how many Indians were present.  He could only see part of their camp and he did not sufficiently reconnoiter prior to attacking.  He left Gatling guns behind because he was worried they would slow his troops down. His forces were split up when he attacked.  

All around poor judgment on Custer's part.

 

Desert Wolverine

November 22nd, 2021 at 4:39 PM ^

Should  just let this be, but it takes my mind off of whether the guys can pull it out on Saturday.  There were a couple of equipment decisions made before the 7th left Ft. Lincoln  You mentioned the Gatling guns, which would have been inconsequential against the Sioux tactics, also would have been impossible to drag through the hilly terrain they were traveling through.  The bigger, and more devastating decision was to leave their sabers behind.  The tactics Custer set up that day were exactly what had worked 2 years earlier, with a small blocking force on one side, and a saber charge through the village by the rest.  Instead, Reno advanced to carbine range of the village, dismounted and started shooting.  At first panic started to spread, but then they noticed, hey no one is getting hit. They gathered the men who were off to the west, attacked Reno, damn near wiping that brigade out, and then went looking for the rest.  The standard saber charge by Reno would have dramatically altered the result.  As far as Custer's estimation of how many people were there, part of that comes form  the failure of Crook's column to the south.  Another couple thousand troopers were supposed to be coming up form Ft Fetterman.  They ran into some resistance, and went scurrying home.  He didn't even send messengers out to the north to let Custer and Terry know there were big problems with the three pronged plan.

There is a great book by N Philbrick Custer, Sittng Bull and the Last stand that goes over the battle and also the following years for Sitting Bull.  It isn't a Custer was a Brave man, who failed, nor a Custer was an idiot, but more of the effects of cascading decisions resulting in an outcome.

One little nuance form the book, taken form accounts from Sioux Warriors,  apparently toward the end of elimination of Custer's brigade, there was one officer who jumped on his horse and made a break for it to the east.  Somehow he got all the way through and got away a couple miles.  But then, out of guilt sham whatever shot himself.  Years later after a fire had swept throghthe area, they found a mans skull with a bullet hole in it.  What stories we might have learned form him, oh well.

As far as the poster and the "vagina's hanging form their uniforms", keep in mind desecration of vanquished corpses has a long history amongst indigenous people all around the globe, and the Sioux were not adverse to the practice.  I am not condoning the fact that troopers did it, but you are taking things way out of context to look at those behaviors now.

 

 

RGard

November 22nd, 2021 at 4:47 PM ^

Me personally?  I would have brought the Gatling guns even if it had slowed me down.  To be fair, it would have slowed Custer down and he wanted to move as quickly as the Indians could. As for not knowing just how big the Indian camp was, that's on Custer as commander on the scene.

I'll read up more on the sabers.  I was under the impression they were no longer considered effective in a fast moving battle.

Desert Wolverine

November 22nd, 2021 at 7:32 PM ^

I admit to being a military history geek, and have been to as many battle sites at the time of year in which it took place to try and get a glimpse into what went on.  Once Custer's brigade de-horsed, it was all over but the shouting.  The sabers were still effective in open movement as in attacking the village that would have been on flat relatively open land.  If you have ever been to Little Bighorn, you will see that it is such rolling country, with the exception the bottom land along the rivers, that any of the horse drawn wheeled conveyances were a real detriment. That was one reason why Benteen and crew couldn't move very fast to reinforce, well that and the fact they were getting attacked as well. But it left Custer's men with just the ammo they carried

Desert Wolverine

November 22nd, 2021 at 7:24 PM ^

Point accepted and concurred with.  It was/is/always will be a de-humanizing act used to whip up violent behavior.  My issue was with my perception of what was being said meant a one way behavior.  It is a classic chicken/egg conundrum about who was first.  My point is that once the violence had started both sides would head in that direction

BlueMk1690

November 22nd, 2021 at 4:25 PM ^

I somehow feel very reluctant about considering Custer to be a role model for our side. I mean he's not exactly the type of guy whose example I'd want to follow.

 

 

MadMatt

November 22nd, 2021 at 4:33 PM ^

Ah, the paradox of a good cavalry commander. Brave, decisive, stupid. For desperate charges, he's your guy. For competent management, he needs adult supervision.

As Napoleon said of Marshall Murat (apologies for the early 19th Century misogyny): "before the battle he more than a man, and afterwards he is less than a woman."

michengin87

November 22nd, 2021 at 5:09 PM ^

This is a great story and one I feel I should know.  I truly did have 2 great great uncles die at Gettysburg and one lost a leg with the 57th Pennsylvania Infantry Regiment.  Their names are inscribed on the monuments.  I obviously didn't know any of them but certainly proud of their heroism.  One other brother survived Gettysburg and saw it through to the end, earning a Congressional Medal of Honor for capturing the confederate flag at Sailor's Creek a few days before the Confederate surrender at Appomattox.

I also urge us to push back those gray clad invaders to our South with all our might.  Go Blue!

 

Wolverrrrrrroudy

November 22nd, 2021 at 6:11 PM ^

ha - I read because believe it or not George Custer is a distant cousin of mine.  And my dad grandpa etc. have read much about his life.  It is a shame that he is so maligned by history, but that’s the way that it goes.

Let’s get this one Wolverines…. Come on you Wolverines!!!

bluecanuk

November 22nd, 2021 at 8:47 PM ^

I am also a history nut, from Michigan and a Michigan grad (1977) so I read all the  Michigan history I can get my hands on. Have been to the little a big horn area and worked close to it in nothern Wyoming near Cody in the oil patch huge valleys and rolling country. About 30 years ago there was a huge grassfire in the battlefield area and they recovered many artifacts including human remains - once the Sioux and Their allies got organized it as an ax kicking. national Geographic did a great story and changed some conventional wisdom at the time. When it went bad Many of the soldiers tried to surrender and were massacred often run down and shot in the ditch. Custer tried to collect the women and children presumably as shields but when the plan went astray well as Mike Tyson said everyone has a plan until you hit them in the mouth.

Two other great historical story lines are worth the reading for fans of Michigan History. the wildfires are also a great story - my ancestors were in the middle of the two wildfires in the Thumb in the later 1800s. The University of Michigan library in the home to the Polar Bears story - the contingent from Michigan and Indiana sent to arctic Russia in WW1 to destabilized the Bolshovek Russians. My favourite book - the Romance of Company E- my grandfather was there and had little good to say about war and especially the British leadership. They spent most of their time surviving cutting wood and hunting food. The British in Archangle “getting all the wiskey and girls”

 

MarcusBrooks

November 22nd, 2021 at 8:39 PM ^

Of we had only made the tackle on 3rd and 9 in the backfield the play before that one where would we be?

Osu had a shaky FG kicker hi amd

would have been forced to try to tie it from long range 

If our injured qb hadn’t had 3 turnovers 2 of which led directly to osu TDs and then fumbled the ball at the goal line when we were about to score where would we be?

fhe spot as bad but we had that game and gave it away by poor qb play 

Durham Blue

November 23rd, 2021 at 12:27 AM ^

Jim Harbaugh is the type of guy that would print this out and read it to his players just before the OSU game.

Then in his postgame presser he would use the word "outflank" numerous times.