Bama fan logic indicates we should share national championship

Dit der her ball team! 

Um that's not Fred, that's definitely Bill Dauterive using a pseudonym. 

Also "bama fan logic". Is that a thing?

I think Fred would agree. Remove conference championships. Remove conferences. Remove the CFP. Remove all bowls. A single season of single elimination. Last one left is Alabama...err the winner. 

I understand the frustration because Bama literally destroyed Georgia

They beat them pretty badly, but I don't think they left a literal trail of wreckage, Gen. Sherman-style.

Is the point of the CFP committee to choose — as best as they’re able — the best teams in the country or the four best conference champions? I like that it’s the former — I want the four best teams regardless of conference or when in the season their losses occurred. Because we’re lying to ourselves if we say that GA isn’t one of the best college football teams. They are. So is Alabama. 

The ostensible purpose of the CFP committee is to determine the four best teams in the US. You can argue they made a mistake, but choosing GA for the CFP wasn’t one of them. The SEC happened to have two of the top teams in college football. That’s all.

The “for some reason“ of which you speak is that SEC pride is essentially a veiled stands-in for antebellum Southern identity, much like Confederate flags and the myth of the lost cause. It is another tribal differentiator of pride that takes precedence over individual school affiliation to stick it to the Yankees.

While I know its crackpot crazy, I want to believe that the SEC championship game was rigged. I just dont believe Georgia can look that bad, and a few weeks later, that good. A two loss Bama wouldnt even sniff the playoffs, so they needed to get in at all costs. 

I'm not sure the SEC Championship game counts because Georgia's best receiver, George Pickens, was out.

I've lived in SEC land for the last 12 years or so, and I still just can't wrap my head around cheering for the conference.  I've had conversations with people saying that it hurts your time more than it helps them if Alabama wins another National Championship, but they just don't see it that way.  I do understand to some extent wanting to have someone to cheer for and have some sense of "winning" once your team is out of the running, but man, SEC love goes way beyond that.  I suppose I would cheer for random B1G teams in bowl games because those games really are irrelevant in the big picture, but never for OSU in playoff/NC games because again - them winning just makes things harder on us.

Part of me also thinks "Man, if UGA had just showed up in the SEC Championship, we would have beaten Cincy then..." then I realize that would probably end with "...Gotten destroyed by Georgia 10 days later than we actually did."

I agree this could be a scenario in the future.  However, this has literally never been an issue in the BIG.  There have never been two teams in the BIG championship game that probably both deserved to be in the CFP.  The OSU/M game up to this point, has also never been a determining factor since the CFP started.  We have been terrible before this year and OSU already had one loss before playing us this year.  2 losses effectively rules out anyone.  Now this could definitely be a factor in the future, but so far, it hasn’t been.

After watching Bama beat UGA, I would’ve agreed with fred.  After watching them dominate both fronts against us and Bama, I don’t think anyone has a leg to stand on to say they weren’t the best team.

I enjoy your hurdling, sir.

They also have the worst loss of the four playoff teams, to 8-4 Texas A&M.

Bang, said Max. No, said Ruby.

(okay, I'll leave now ...)

He's. Too SECsy for his logic.

he has such a vile appearance and demeanor, but you have to give him credit for handling that toothless wonder.  'do you live alone or do you have someone that looks after you?', was a pretty good line. 

Awhile back I sort of got the SEC bias.  Peyton Manning was at TN and those years carried their rep for awhile and Florida, Auburn won National championships before Alabama tore through the record books.  On top of that Michigan was down and we lost to Miss St and South Carolina who were ascending alongside Ole Miss who paid off Laquan Treadwell.   Now, all of those teams other than Bama, Georgia and this year’s Ole Miss are a mess.  Don’t know if it is the portal, NIL or what, but feels like the tide is turning.

Does any fanbase suffer more heartbreaking losses than Bama's?

At least Alabama is ahead of MIssippi.

He is basically just Valenti but in the south. Just says things to make people mad, and "backs it up" with cherry picked stats. Long rants about how "pathetic and sad" it is that whatever school only has some stat that is bad. Anytime I hear someone talk about a coaches record on the road against top 10 or top 5 schools, I turn it off instantly. They cherry pick the stats, give no context to the stat, and act like they are so much smarter than other fans. 

They have listeners that have been listening to their stations for years, long before they got there, and do not know any better. I wish I could have these people listen to some much much better podcasts for a few days and free their minds of this trash. 

Or when Bama didn't even win the SEC West but made the playoff anyway.