I don't understand the reasoning. Unless there's some legal basis for denying a transfer—and it doesn't seem there is anymore—why would a university put itself on public display being petty?
I love that Michigan does such a great job of developing offensive line players.
When I teach, I consider my primary task not simply to convey information but to develop habits of thought and encourage curiosity that enables students to develop themselves.
However, your message feels needlessly combative. It feels as if you're saying "I posted about something I like and if you don't like it, you're wrong. Also, I'm a rebel so I posted in an unusual way and if you don't like that, you're wrong."
You make a good point about the issue of prestige jobs.
However, broadening the scope to a more philosophical level shows two faults:
1. Prestige schools and prestige jobs do not necessarily equate to quality. (Them ain't sour grapes. No legacy—unless my dad's Nebraska degree counts—I got into Ivies undergrad but, paying my own way, couldn't afford them. Then after my UM degree, I picked up graduate degrees.)
2. Over-reliance on prestige schools is innately anti-democratic.
What are you, a commie or somethin'?! Oh, yeah. I guess so.
You're also right. Elite schools have perpetuated a caste system. As NittanyFan noted above, virtually a half century of the Supreme Court comes from either Harvard or Yale. That's reprehensible, and innately undemocratic.
However, I have a slim hope that pressure is building to reform things.
Recent Comments
Wow! And Go, Blue!
Wow. I just noticed Michigan got outhit, 7 for the Hoosiers, only two (2!) hits for Blue! Great win.
11th Tournament Championship!
Bonnie Tholl: "We don't have All Americans. We've got a team."
BLUE! CHAMPIONS!
3-1! Keep it goin', Blue!
All they'd really have to do is hire Craig to BE their archives.
Unabominable!
Wow! That photo finish is great to watch. Thanks for posting.
Go, Brady! Go, Blue!
Great! Go, Blue!
Go, Blue!
Oh, ... golf.
Seeing "Coaches Handicaps," I thought we were going to get analysis of Captain Third Base, Kelly Krying, Hugh Hypocrisy, etc.
Thanks for posting.
Go, Blue!
Better to hire Matt Alfred than Alfred the Great?
Did I play that right?
Tuggin' Tucker?
Isn't his name simply Tugger now?
Rest in peace
Solecismic, your label is great.
Just a schmear.
I figure "Title says it all" is a defensive move, designed to fend off complaints.
Good luck with that.
Go, Blue!
Go, Blue!
Though RPI has value, it does lead to the irony of worrying about the value of a win.
Cuz you've got a gift.
Thanks. Lots of good explanation. Are you a teacher?
Good for him!
Thanks for posting.
I was wondering when you'd weigh in.
Respect.
"May recruited players that would get in. This seems like a better approach."
Sometimes the punch lines are subtle.
Not to mention how cool it is to have a player named Vlad.
I remember when we moved to Michigan, my sixth-grade teacher gave us a lesson on iodized salt and Michigan's role.
Welcome! An important addition to the team.
Welcome Seth's mother-in-law's school's family's kid!
MSU parents, and he still chooses Michigan. Smart kid.
I'm not surprised. I just don't understand why a college would do it.
We all look ridiculous sometimes but why do it deliberately?
I don't understand the reasoning. Unless there's some legal basis for denying a transfer—and it doesn't seem there is anymore—why would a university put itself on public display being petty?
I love that Michigan does such a great job of developing offensive line players.
When I teach, I consider my primary task not simply to convey information but to develop habits of thought and encourage curiosity that enables students to develop themselves.
Brilliant. (I was gonna copy your joke with my word but your stunt deserves to crow alone.)
Because Sparties can't handle anything tougher than a light summer breeze.
Thanks for posting a recap.
Thanks to the team for the psych out!
Beautiful. I send my condolences to you and your family.
Congratulations!
And cool pic. Which one is your daughter?
16-4! Big Ten Champs!
Rest in peace
I upvoted your post for the information. Thanks.
However, your message feels needlessly combative. It feels as if you're saying "I posted about something I like and if you don't like it, you're wrong. Also, I'm a rebel so I posted in an unusual way and if you don't like that, you're wrong."
Welcome! Go, Blue.
Great comeback! Go, Blue!
Thanks for posting. Upvote for the fun account. Though I told myself I didn't need another one, I ended up reading the whole thing.
Also, part of the upvote for adding something new on Diaries. Two weeks of "The NCAA" and "The NFL Draft" was enough.
You make a good point about the issue of prestige jobs.
However, broadening the scope to a more philosophical level shows two faults:
1. Prestige schools and prestige jobs do not necessarily equate to quality. (Them ain't sour grapes. No legacy—unless my dad's Nebraska degree counts—I got into Ivies undergrad but, paying my own way, couldn't afford them. Then after my UM degree, I picked up graduate degrees.)
2. Over-reliance on prestige schools is innately anti-democratic.
By the way, I believe the financing/donation issue is mixed.
On one hand, opening admissions to a broader pool might diminish donations.
On the other hand, the Ivies are in an arms race with endowments far beyond solid fiscal management.
What are you, a commie or somethin'?! Oh, yeah. I guess so.
You're also right. Elite schools have perpetuated a caste system. As NittanyFan noted above, virtually a half century of the Supreme Court comes from either Harvard or Yale. That's reprehensible, and innately undemocratic.
However, I have a slim hope that pressure is building to reform things.
There are lots of good colleges offering good education beyond the elite names everyone knows.